Is paying an annual fee worth it?

Some credit cards with the most worthwhile rewards may charge annual fees. But you don’t necessarily have to pay an annual fee to get a credit card that offers rewards. There are many excellent credit cards on the market that don’t charge an annual fee, including cards that offer the ability to earn cash back, travel miles and other types of credit card rewards.

What is an annual fee and why do some credit cards have them?

An annual fee for a credit card is the price a cardholder must pay for continuing to own the card. It’s billed yearly, typically on the date the card was first issued to you.

If a card issuer charges an annual fee for a card, it’s usually to offset the costs of rewards the card offers. But just because a card offers rewards doesn’t mean those rewards will be worth more than the annual fee. If you’re considering applying for a credit card with an annual fee, make sure the rewards offered by the issuer outweigh the cost of the fee. Here are a few scenarios where it may or may not make sense to pay an annual fee.

When it could make sense to pay a credit card annual fee

Here are a few scenarios where it might make sense to apply for a credit card with an annual fee.

You’d get top-tier rewards (especially travel) that justify an annual fee

Generally, an annual fee is a trade-off for top-notch cash back, miles, points or various other rewards. Travel credit cards, in particular, are typically known for their annual fees. Some premium travel credit cards charge fees in the hundreds of dollars. For example, The Platinum Card® from American Express charges a $695 annual fee.

Some issuers offer two versions of the same credit card: one with an annual fee and one either at a lower annual fee or without a fee altogether. The rewards for cards with no annual fee are usually not as generous as those with fees.

For example, the Capital One VentureOne Rewards Credit Card has no annual fee and gives you unlimited 1.25X miles on all purchases. However, if you pay the $95 fee for the Capital One Venture Rewards Credit Card, you can earn an unlimited 2X miles on every purchase — that’s about 60 percent more miles. Then there’s the Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card, which charges a $395 annual and still only awards 2X miles on your purchases, but also throws in extra travel perks and statement credits.

You’d earn a hefty sign-up bonus that offsets the annual fee

Sign-up bonuses, also called welcome bonuses, require a certain amount of spending within an introductory period, and many cards without an annual fee come with these offers. However, the welcome bonus amount — and spending threshold — is typically higher for cards with annual fees.

Using the same cards as an example, Capital One Venture Rewards cardholders pay a $95 annual fee but also have the opportunity to earn 75,000 miles once they spend $4,000 on purchases within three months of opening the account, plus receive a one-time $250 Capital One Travel credit to use within your first cardholder year. Capital One VentureOne Rewards cardholders, on the other hand, only have the opportunity to earn 20,000 bonus miles after spending $500 on purchases in the first three months.

Capital One miles are worth 1 cent per mile when redeemed for travel statement credits. That means the Venture’s welcome bonus is worth $750 when redeemed this way (plus another $250 credit for Capital One Travel), while the VentureOne’s welcome bonus is only worth $200. Even if you subtract the cost of the annual fee, you still end up with far more value from the Venture card.

However, you also have to keep in mind the spending requirements. The higher sign-up bonus from an annual fee card is useless if you don’t spend enough (or worse, overspend and go into debt) to reach the spending threshold.

You’d enjoy elite travel features that only a credit card with an annual fee can give you

When you pay a credit card annual fee, expect a few extra perks. To make travel experiences as hassle free as possible for cardholders, travel cards with an annual fee often feature travel benefits such as:

• Trip cancellation insurance
• Lost luggage reimbursement
• Travel accident insurance
• No foreign transaction fees
• Free checked bags

Some cards go even further, offering features like airport lounge access, rideshare credits, annual travel credits, credits toward TSA PreCheck or Global Entry application fees, elite status at various hotels and more.

The higher the annual fee, the better the benefits. Premium credit cards with high annual fees, like the Amex Platinum Card with a $695 annual fee and the Chase Sapphire Reserve® with a $550 annual fee, deliver a slew of high-end rewards to cardholders.

When a credit card offers the right combination of rewards and features, paying an annual fee – even what may seem a high one – could upgrade your travel experience and save you money in the long run.

You’re rebuilding your credit and can afford to do so with a card that charges an annual fee

Some credit cards for people with bad credit charge annual fees, although there are exceptions. If your credit history puts many cards out of reach, you might consider applying for a credit card with a low annual fee to help you build your credit until you can qualify for a better card. One example is the Self – Credit Builder Account with Secured Visa® Credit Card, which is geared toward people with poor or no credit history and charges an annual fee of $25.

Another option is a secured credit card, which requires an upfront security deposit to establish your line of credit with the card. The benefit of these cards is that the security deposit is one-time and refundable, whereas annual fees are recurring and non-refundable. However, security deposits may require a bit more upfront cash. Many require at least $200, while annual fees for these cards are usually under $100.

When it doesn’t make sense to pay an annual fee

We’ve established that a card with an annual fee can be worth it, but whether it actually is depends on how much you charge to the card and how often you use the benefits the card offers. Here are a few scenarios when it may make more sense to steer clear of annual fee cards.

You don’t spend enough to make up for the cost of the annual fee

For every card with an annual fee, there should be a point at which you spend enough to recoup the cost of your annual fee. For example, if your card earns 2 percent cash back on everything and charges a $100 annual fee, you would have to spend $5,000 before your earnings offset the cost of the annual fee ($5,000 x .02 = $100).

If you were trying to stick to a budget of, say, $500 per credit card bill, it would take you 10 months to earn $100 in cash back. In the remaining two months of the year, you’d earn $20 in cash back, meaning you only come out $20 ahead for the entire year. You wouldn’t be losing money, but you also wouldn’t be gaining much.

If you stuck to your monthly budget of $500 and instead used a card with no annual fee that earns 1.5 percent cash back on everything, you’d come out $90 ahead for the year ($6,000 x .015 = $90).

If you’re deciding between a card with an annual fee and a card without one, it’s worth doing some quick math to estimate your net earnings.

You won’t use the additional benefits that a card with an annual fee would provide

Card benefits and perks are sometimes harder to assign value to. Though many benefits, like free checked bags and airport lounge access do have concrete monetary value, they’re worthless if you don’t use them.

For example, among other benefits, the Blue Cash Preferred® Card from American Express – which offers a first-year $0 intro annual fee and then charges a $95 annual fee – also offers a complimentary ShopRunner membership. This service offers free expedited shipping when you shop with select merchants. That sounds pretty great, but you should take the time to investigate the participating merchants. Do you shop often with them? Enough that free expedited shipping will be valuable? Then, decide whether you’re likely to remember to make your purchases through ShopRunner.

If your answer to any of those questions is no, that benefit shouldn’t be a factor in your decision. You might find that the card’s rewards rates are high enough to justify the annual fee alone, or you might decide that it isn’t worth it and the Blue Cash Everyday® Card from American Express with no annual fee meets your needs.

You have credit card debt and can’t afford to add a card with an annual fee to your portfolio

Credit card rewards are a nice bonus for people who can pay their statements in full each month. But if you’re working on paying down a credit card debt balance, it’s probably not a good idea to add another charge to the mix. The average credit card interest rate is over 20 percent, so it’s best to put every extra dollar toward debt before you start pursuing rewards on a card with an annual fee.

Your card’s features diminish after the first year

Some cards pack a lot of benefits into the first year, from boosted rewards rates and welcome bonuses to memberships with popular retailers. While these may offset the annual fee in year one, you should take them out of the equation to gauge value for the following years.

What to do if your card’s annual fee isn’t worth it

When you assess the credit cards in your wallet and decide that the annual fee isn’t worth it, you might think your only option is to close the card, but here are some other ways to handle it.

• Call customer service and ask whether they can waive the annual fee. Maybe they won’t, but it never hurts to ask.
• Maximize your rewards usage to offset the cost.
• Request a retention offer through customer service if you are considering closing your card.
• Request to swap your credit card for one with no annual fee.
• If you’re a member of the U.S. military, ask if your military status could entitle you to a fee waiver.

Since closing your credit card could negatively impact your credit score, it might not be the best step to take after realizing that the annual fee isn’t worth it for you. So choosing to switch credit cards, get the fee waived or shift your rewards usage could make it more affordable without negatively affecting your credit score.

The bottom line

How much would you pay for a top rewards credit card? Less than $100 per year? $125? How about $550? If you want to know whether a credit card annual fee is worth it, take a careful look at all of the rewards and benefits the credit card offers. Then, ask yourself whether the value you would realistically get from those benefits will outweigh the cost of the annual fee.

If the annual fee feels too expensive, or if you aren’t sure whether you’ll really use all of the features the credit card offers, you might want to consider a credit card with no annual fee instead.