Deed Of Trust Vs. Mortgage

The term “mortgage” is used whenever a person buys a home with a loan, but it’s not always the right terminology. Some states don’t use mortgages. Instead, they use a document known as a deed of trust (sometimes called a “trust deed”), a legally binding contract for a real estate transaction. Though it seems to serve the same purpose, a deed of trust is technically not a mortgage.

That begs the question: What’s the difference between a deed of trust and a mortgage?

Anyone buying a home should understand the nuances of a deed of trust compared to a mortgage — and which they’re signing, of course. So let’s dive in.

What is a deed of trust?

To get started, let’s define “deed.” This is the legal document that shows who has title (ownership) to a piece of property. There are different types of deeds, but here, we’re focusing not on the deed itself but on what happens to it.

So, what is a deed of trust? It’s a deed that gets put into a trust. Like a mortgage, a deed of trust agreement obligates the borrower to repay a home loan, with the home serving as collateral if they default. But the difference between a deed of trust and a mortgage lies with who holds the deed during the repayment period.

How does a deed of trust work?

To understand how a deed of trust works, consider that there are three parties in a deed of trust: the lender, the homebuyer/borrower, and the trustee. The trustee is a third party who plays the role of intermediary for the real estate transaction.

In the deed of trust vs. mortgage conversation, this is a key differentiator. Mortgages don’t loop in the third party; the agreement is just between the lender and the borrower.

With a deed of trust, the lender gives the borrower the funds to make the home purchase. In exchange, the borrower provides the lender with a promissory note. The promissory note outlines the terms of the loan and the borrower’s promise (hence the name) to pay. (So, the promissory note is just one component of the overall deed of trust. Specifically, it outlines the borrower’s obligation to repay the loan so they can keep the home.

At this point, with a deed of trust, the borrower transfers the real property interest to the trustee. (The “real property interest” is simply a term used to describe the right to that real estate property.)

In most cases, the trustee in a deed of trust is a title company or escrow company, though it can be another party such as an attorney or bank.

Deeds of trust and default

Here’s why who’s holding the title matters. Because the trustee holds the interest in the property, the trustee can take action if the borrower fails to make payments on time or fails to follow all that was agreed to in the promissory note.

If the borrower stops paying the loan, for example, the trustee has the legal right to take full control of the property. The trustee’s job is to correct the default and repay the lender. To do this, the trustee may have to sell the home — and in most deeds of trust, it has the power to do that without seeking formal court permission to foreclose on it.

State laws on deeds of trusts

“A deed of trust is not recognized by all states,” Kevin Frankel, attorney with Fiffik Law Group, a LegalShield provider law firm, explains. Deeds of trust are used in 33 states and the District of Columbia; both they and mortgages are allowed in nine states.

In the states that permit both mortgages and deeds of trust, such as Arizona and Michigan, the lender gets to choose which to use — and will probably opt for the deed of trust due to the easier foreclosure proceedings if the borrower defaults. If you have a deed of trust, you’ll usually face a nonjudicial foreclosure — meaning the trustee can just impose it. If you have a mortgage, your lender will need to seek a court judgment to seize the home.

When the lender chooses or is required to use a deed of trust, the rights and processes for the trustee to follow vary by state. In some situations, the trustee merely holds the lien on the property and is given only a few rights in terms of handling defaults on the loan. The terms of the mortgage agreement and promissory note will outline what the ultimate contract requires, so be sure to read the fine print.

Deed of trust vs. mortgage

To recap, both a deed of trust and mortgage involve agreements between the lender and the borrower (i.e. the homebuyer) that lay out the borrower’s promise to repay the loan. Both also clearly state that the home serves as collateral for the loan, meaning if the borrower stops repayment the lender has recourse.

As attorney Amy Loftsgordon, a legal editor at Nolo, explains it, “By having the borrower sign a mortgage or deed of trust, the lender has a way to get its money back if the borrower doesn’t keep the promise to make the payments — by foreclosing its lien and selling the property to a new owner at a foreclosure sale.”

A deed of trust, however, adds a third party into the agreement: a trustee, an unbiased third party that holds the property’s title while the loan is being repaid. If the borrower fails to repay the loan, the trustee has the right to foreclose on the property.

Similarities between deeds of trusts and mortgages

Both deeds of trusts and mortgages are:

• Agreements to exchange home loan proceeds for a borrower’s agreement to repay the loan
• Agreements that use the home as collateral during the repayment period
• Governed by state law
• “Filed with the office that records land records,” Frankel says.

Differences between deeds of trusts and mortgages

The key differences between a deed of trust and a mortgage are:

• Who holds the home title during the repayment period: With a deed of trust, it’s a third party, while the lender or borrower holds the title with a mortgage, depending on state law.
• The number of parties involved: With a deed of trust, there are three (borrower, lender, trustee), while a mortgage has just two (borrower, lender).
• What happens if you default: “With a few exceptions, mortgages are usually foreclosed judicially (through the court system), while deeds of trust are usually foreclosed through an out-of-court (nonjudicial) process,” Loftsgordon says. Judicial foreclosure is a lengthy process that tends to be costly because of legal fees. With a deed of trust, the lender can avoid the courts.

Bottom line

Anyone buying a home with a deed of trust should know that the home can be foreclosed quickly, without any legal proceeding in a court of law. In other words, there may not be an opportunity to get caught up on the loan.

Homebuyers or people taking on a new home loan should take the time to find out whether they have a mortgage or a deed of trust. In many cases, this will dictate how any legal proceedings will be carried out if the terms of the contract are breached.

To make sure you can afford to make your home loan payments on a long-term basis, you can use this Bankrate calculator.

Deed of trust FAQs

• How does a deed of trust impact foreclosure?
  

  Under a deed of trust, the property can be sold if the borrower is in default without going through a costly, lengthy legal procedure. The process is known as a nonjudicial foreclosure.

  The deed of trust allows the trustee to maintain the controlling interest in the property until the debt is paid in full. Any deed of trust with a power-of-sale clause, which is nearly always present, allows the trustee to sell the home without needing to foreclose on it first. Alternatively, borrowers may pursue a deed in lieu of foreclosure.

• Can a deed of trust be transferred?
  

  Deed of trust transfers operate similarly to mortgage transfers, though neither one is especially common. Whether buying a house with a deed of trust or a mortgage, the transferee will most likely need to enter into a new arrangement as part of the sale. However, in certain circumstances, like a property owner’s death, divorce or living will proceeding, both mortgage and deeds of trust can be transferred.

  The appropriate authorities (usually a municipal government) will have to record the transfer, just like they would for a purchase agreement. And, as Frankel explains, “Based on the terms of the deed of trust, it may be assigned if all three parties agree in writing.”

• What is the difference between a deed of trust and promissory note?
  

  To compare a deed of trust to a promissory note, think of the deed of trust as the whole agreement while the promissory note is just one part. The promissory note focuses on the borrower’s commitment to repay the lender. The deed of trust is an overarching document that specifies what happens if the borrower doesn’t live up to that promise (i.e., defaults on the loan).