If you own a second home, travel for long stretches, or leave a property mostly unused, 2026 may feel different for one simple reason: your house now generates a data trail. Smart meters and advanced utility systems can show extremely detailed patterns of electricity and water use, and low-use patterns can raise questions about whether a property is truly occupied. Researchers have shown it’s possible to infer occupancy from electricity-consumption patterns, which is why utility data keeps popping up in housing policy conversations. And while there isn’t one nationwide vacancy tax or “empty house fine,” several cities already use vacancy-style rules, and enforcement often happens through audits that demand evidence.
Vacancy Tax Audits Start With Utility Patterns
Many places that charge a vacancy tax rely on self-declarations first, then audits when something looks off. Vancouver’s Empty Homes Tax, for example, requires an annual declaration and outlines an audit process and penalties for late, unpaid, or false declarations. Smart meters make “something looks off” easier to detect because they create frequent, time-stamped readings instead of a simple monthly bill total.
Researchers have shown that vacancy intervals can be inferred from electricity-use data, which helps explain why low-use patterns can attract scrutiny. If you’re legitimately exempt or occupied, your best defense is documentation that supports your story, not guesses about what your usage “should” look like.
“Baseline Usage” Can Still Suggest Nobody Lives There
Even when a home has some power draw, smart meter data can show whether usage looks like a lived-in routine or a mostly empty building. A refrigerator hum, a router blink, and occasional HVAC cycles can create a steady baseline that doesn’t match normal daily life. That’s not proof by itself, but it can be used as a prompt to ask for evidence, especially if you claimed full-time occupancy or rental use.
Occupancy detection research specifically focuses on extracting vacant intervals from consumption curves, which highlights how patterns matter more than a single bill. If you split time between homes, keep a simple day log and pair it with travel confirmations so you can respond calmly if questions arise.
Move-In, Move-Out, And “Turn-On” Events Leave Time Stamps
Utility accounts often record service-start, service-stop, and billing changes that line up neatly with occupancy claims. If you shut off service, put an account on a special status, or repeatedly “turn on” utilities only for short bursts, that timing can conflict with your declarations.
In audit-heavy programs, the point is consistency across records, not just what you meant to do. Vancouver’s enforcement materials emphasize that owners may be requested to submit evidence during an audit and that missing or incorrect evidence can delay the process. If you rely on an exemption, keep the supporting paperwork in one folder so you can produce it without scrambling.
Low-Use Data Can Trigger A Second Look When A City Already Has A Vacancy Rule
Not every city has a vacancy policy, but where these rules exist, they can carry meaningful costs. Oakland’s Vacant Property Tax, for example, lays out an annual tax amount and defines when a property is considered vacant under the local rules. The Institute on Taxation and Economic
Policy notes that vacancy taxes are increasingly used as a policy tool, even though they’re not a cure-all for housing shortages. If your area has a vacancy-style ordinance, the risk is less about a surprise “new” law and more about stronger enforcement of an existing one. Treat your local rules like a recurring compliance task, not a one-time form you’ll “deal with later.”
Privacy Concerns Are Growing As Evidence Requests Get More Detailed
When governments ask for more proof, homeowners often worry about how much personal data they’re expected to hand over. Reporting on Vancouver’s empty homes audits has highlighted objections that the audit process can feel intrusive, which is part of why this topic keeps getting attention.
Vancouver also explicitly discusses privacy obligations and states that audits request evidence and follow an established process. If you’re uncomfortable, don’t ignore notices—respond, ask what specific documents are required, and consider getting tax or legal help for your jurisdiction. The worst outcomes usually come from missed deadlines, not from a well-documented, on-time response.
The Practical Way To Avoid An “Empty House” Surprise
Start by checking whether your city or state has any vacancy tax, empty-homes tax, or vacant-property rules at all, because many places don’t. Where the rule exists, your goal is consistency: your declarations, your leases, your travel days, and your supporting documents should all tell the same story. Vancouver’s materials show how real the deadlines and penalties can be, which is why treating this like routine compliance pays off. Smart meters don’t automatically “fine” anyone, but detailed utility data can make it easier to challenge claims that don’t match the record. If you stay organized and respond quickly, you reduce the chance that a paperwork problem turns into an expensive mess.
Have you ever dealt with a vacancy or “proof of occupancy” request—what documentation was hardest to track down?
What to Read Next…
The 183-Day Trap: 5 New Digital “Breadcrumbs” Blue States Are Using to Tax Florida Snowbirds in 2026
Older Adults Are Seeing Delays in State Tax Refund Processing
Chicago Retirees Are Seeing Delays in Property Tax Corrections
How Property Taxes Are Forcing Seniors Out of Paid-Off Homes
What Happens After You Miss a Property Tax Deadline: Penalties, Interest, and Enforcement
Read the full article here
